{
  "title": "What sells in NFTs — a source-led market audit",
  "research_date": "2026-11-21",
  "scope": "Desk audit of provider snapshots, auction-house results, marketplace-labelled sales, official product documentation and collection pages. This is not a wallet-level certification of organic sales.",
  "main_finding": "Demand is segmented. Physical-backed collectibles trade on underlying goods and transaction mechanics; established character brands trade on distribution and identity; specialist art buyers respond to an artist, a coherent series and a credible process. None establishes demand for an unknown new studio.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "courtyard-market",
      "title": "CoinGecko — Courtyard.io",
      "url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/nft/courtyard-io",
      "period": "Provider-displayed rolling 24 hours; fetched November 21, 2026. Cached page freshness is not synchronized with other sources.",
      "type": "provider snapshot",
      "observation": "12,789 sales and 259.91 ETH volume; 459,732 assets. The opened page showed 139,882 owner addresses and a 0.00320 ETH floor in its marketplace table. A search excerpt displayed a different owner count, so owner counts are not used for cross-source calculations.",
      "limit": "Floor is an asking price. Sales are transactions, not unique buyers. Buybacks, packs and repeated trading may affect turnover."
    },
    {
      "id": "pudgy-market",
      "title": "CoinGecko — Pudgy Penguins",
      "url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/nft/pudgy-penguins",
      "period": "Provider-displayed rolling 24 hours; fetched November 21, 2026.",
      "type": "provider snapshot",
      "observation": "4 sales and 9.26 ETH volume; 8,888 assets and 4,998 owner addresses. Displayed floor: approximately 2.25 ETH.",
      "limit": "An established collection's floor and turnover do not predict a new character collection's demand. Owners are addresses, not verified people."
    },
    {
      "id": "courtyard-activity",
      "title": "growthepie — Courtyard application analytics",
      "url": "https://www.growthepie.com/applications/courtyard-io",
      "period": "Latest displayed seven-day window; data timestamp November 20, 2026, 05:35:03 UTC in the indexed snapshot.",
      "type": "indexed onchain application metrics",
      "observation": "365.2K transactions, 1.6K active addresses, and $4.6K in gas fees. Transactions were down 6.3% against the prior seven days.",
      "limit": "Application transactions are not NFT sales. Active addresses are not unique buyers. Contract labels and coverage can change."
    },
    {
      "id": "courtyard-product",
      "title": "Courtyard — How it works",
      "url": "https://courtyard.io/about",
      "period": "Official product page fetched November 21, 2026.",
      "type": "operator documentation",
      "observation": "The product includes authenticated vaulted collectibles, physical redemption, packs and buyback offers.",
      "limit": "These mechanics require inventory, custody and fulfilment. Art depicting a card is not an equivalent product. Operator statements are not an independent custody audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "squiggle-auction",
      "title": "Sotheby's — Digital Art Day Auction, February 2025",
      "url": "https://www.sothebys.com/en/auction-catalogue/2025/digital-art-day-auction-NF2502/auction-highlights",
      "period": "Auction held February 12–19, 2025.",
      "type": "auction-house completed-sale result",
      "observation": "Chromie Squiggle #9871 by Snowfro is marked sold at USD 11,430.",
      "limit": "Historical result for an established artist. Use the house's displayed result; do not compare it with an ETH ask as if fees, dates and currencies were identical."
    },
    {
      "id": "botto-sales",
      "title": "SuperRare — Botto 2026 collection",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/collection/1-0x3cb787d48c34cca29653f54efc9112b4134b879d",
      "period": "2026 collection; indexed marketplace snapshot retrieved November 21, 2026. Individual settlement dates were not exposed in the accessible snapshot.",
      "type": "marketplace-labelled completed sales",
      "observation": "Digital Cascade Bisects Organic Decay: 1.200 ETH; Hourglass Evacuates Upward: 3.025 ETH; Striped Metamorphosis: 1.000 ETH; Tongue Supports the Brutalist Fortress: 1.100 ETH. These four entries were labelled Sold for, separate from list prices.",
      "limit": "Convenience sample of visible entries, not a representative sample or an independent wallet-funding audit. Cached dollar conversions are excluded."
    },
    {
      "id": "christies-ai",
      "title": "Christie's — Augmented Intelligence results",
      "url": "https://press.christies.com/augmented-intelligence-totals-728784/?lang=eng",
      "period": "Sale closed March 5, 2025.",
      "type": "auction-house result",
      "observation": "Sale total USD 728,784. Refik Anadol's Machine Hallucinations — ISS Dreams — A realized USD 277,200.",
      "limit": "The auction mixed mediums, including physical works. The total is not pure NFT volume. Auction results include buyer's premium, as the sale catalogue specifies."
    },
    {
      "id": "christies-catalogue",
      "title": "Christie's — Augmented Intelligence sale catalogue",
      "url": "https://onlineonly.christies.com/s/augmented-intelligence/lots/3837",
      "period": "February 20–March 5, 2025.",
      "type": "auction catalogue",
      "observation": "The catalogue reports the USD 728,784 sale total and states that sales totals include buyer's premium, while estimates exclude it.",
      "limit": "The difference between estimates and realized prices matters; estimates are not sales."
    },
    {
      "id": "artblocks-listings",
      "title": "Art Blocks — phase by Loren Bednar",
      "url": "https://www.artblocks.io/collection/phase-by-loren-bednar",
      "period": "Collection released August 20, 2021; current page fetched November 21, 2026.",
      "type": "specialist collection listing page",
      "observation": "Fixed edition of 1,024 artworks; 23 listings starting at 0.0899 ETH on the fetched page.",
      "limit": "Listing supply and starting ask are not completed sales or sell-through. This page is evidence of a specialist collecting format, not current demand at that ask."
    },
    {
      "id": "pudgy-distribution",
      "title": "Pudgy Penguins — September 2026 recap",
      "url": "https://huddle.pudgypenguins.com/media/blog/sep-2026-recap",
      "period": "Published September 30, 2026.",
      "type": "official brand account",
      "observation": "The brand describes wholesale retail access, product partnerships, merchandise and collector events.",
      "limit": "Brand-reported distribution is not independently audited NFT revenue. A new design does not inherit this installed audience or its licenses."
    },
    {
      "id": "binance-context",
      "title": "Binance Research — Full-Year 2025 and Themes for 2026",
      "url": "https://public.bnbstatic.com/static/files/research/full-year-2025-and-themes-for-2026.pdf",
      "period": "Year ending December 31, 2025.",
      "type": "research report",
      "observation": "The report describes broad NFT-price contraction and a 55% year-over-year decline in GameFi investment during 2025.",
      "limit": "Historical sector context, not a 2026 year-end result. Game activity does not demonstrate demand for a standalone browser puzzle."
    },
    {
      "id": "wash-method",
      "title": "NFT Wash Trading: Quantifying suspicious behaviour in NFT markets",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.03866",
      "period": "2022 research on an earlier market sample.",
      "type": "primary research paper",
      "observation": "The paper demonstrates that suspicious trading patterns can be investigated through transaction relationships.",
      "limit": "Its historical findings are not used as a present-day wash-trading percentage. Proving independent demand requires more than aggregate volume."
    },
    {
      "id": "artbasel-ubs-collecting-2026",
      "title": "Art Basel and UBS Survey of Global Collecting 2026",
      "url": "https://www.artbasel.com/stories/the-art-basel-and-ubs-survey-of-global-collecting-2026",
      "period": "2026 survey; primary release consulted November 22, 2026.",
      "type": "primary collector survey release",
      "observation": "72% of surveyed high-net-worth collectors reported moderate or significant independent research before buying. The release also describes more selective discovery and private ownership preferences.",
      "limit": "Broad art collector survey. Not an NFT-specific conversion benchmark or evidence of demand for this studio."
    }
  ],
  "sale_sample": [
    {
      "work": "Chromie Squiggle #9871",
      "artist": "Snowfro",
      "amount": 11430,
      "currency": "USD",
      "status": "auction-house sold result",
      "source": "squiggle-auction",
      "sale_period": "February 2025"
    },
    {
      "work": "Digital Cascade Bisects Organic Decay",
      "artist": "Botto",
      "amount": 1.2,
      "currency": "ETH",
      "status": "marketplace labelled sold",
      "source": "botto-sales",
      "sale_period": "individual date unverified; 2026 collection"
    },
    {
      "work": "Hourglass Evacuates Upward",
      "artist": "Botto",
      "amount": 3.025,
      "currency": "ETH",
      "status": "marketplace labelled sold",
      "source": "botto-sales",
      "sale_period": "individual date unverified; 2026 collection"
    },
    {
      "work": "Striped Metamorphosis",
      "artist": "Botto",
      "amount": 1,
      "currency": "ETH",
      "status": "marketplace labelled sold",
      "source": "botto-sales",
      "sale_period": "individual date unverified; 2026 collection"
    },
    {
      "work": "Tongue Supports the Brutalist Fortress",
      "artist": "Botto",
      "amount": 1.1,
      "currency": "ETH",
      "status": "marketplace labelled sold",
      "source": "botto-sales",
      "sale_period": "individual date unverified; 2026 collection"
    },
    {
      "work": "Machine Hallucinations — ISS Dreams — A",
      "artist": "Refik Anadol",
      "amount": 277200,
      "currency": "USD",
      "status": "auction-house realized price",
      "source": "christies-ai",
      "sale_period": "March 2025"
    }
  ],
  "inferences": [
    "Separate the physical-backed market from art. Its underlying goods, packs and buybacks are a different business.",
    "Process and provenance are useful product features: original files, exact hashes, reproducible code and honest medium descriptions.",
    "Recognizable characters need a body of stories and an audience. Three characters can test that attachment; a large random mint cannot manufacture it.",
    "Playable art should work before any NFT release. A public puzzle demonstrates the experience without promising income, access to another game or future development.",
    "Participation is measurable as completed creative exchanges. It does not establish that independent agents will buy tokens."
  ],
  "exclusions": [
    "No floor-price movement is treated as realized profit.",
    "No claim that a wallet address equals a unique person or independent agent.",
    "No market-wide wash-adjusted volume is asserted: CryptoSlam's direct dashboard returned 403, and wallet-level funding/beneficial ownership were not audited.",
    "No claim that a tiny visible sale sample establishes a median for all AI art or a valuation for Steve Bishop's work.",
    "Physical toy sales, application transactions, fungible tokens, liquidity-position NFTs and unsold asks are not added to art-sale totals."
  ],
  "launch_test": {
    "sequence": "Publish all five three-work studio collections. Test generative and surreal stills first; use the character stories and free interactive pieces to learn what people return to. Mint only after platform access and a concrete buyer path exist.",
    "measurement": "Track qualified enquiries, independently completed creative exchanges and actual paid settlements separately. No trackers, enquiries or sales counters have been invented or installed.",
    "success": "A verified independent buyer and completed payment, with net proceeds after actual fees. Views, downloads, demo agents and wallet transfers alone do not qualify."
  },
  "calculations": {
    "botto_four_displayed_sales_total_eth": 6.324999999999999,
    "botto_four_displayed_sales_median_eth": 1.15,
    "courtyard_snapshot_mean_sale_eth": 0.020322933771209636,
    "pudgy_snapshot_mean_sale_eth": 2.315,
    "christies_top_lot_share": 0.38035961272475793
  },
  "catalogue_update": {
    "date": "2026-11-22",
    "works": 33,
    "core_collection_sizes": [
      6,
      9,
      9
    ],
    "interactive_study_sizes": [
      3,
      3
    ],
    "original_triptych": 3,
    "new_chapter": "After the Storm",
    "new_chapter_works": 6,
    "viewing_routes": 4,
    "deep_research": "/research-forensics",
    "design_inference": "Specific relationships and consequential ordinary gestures offer different possible points of personal connection. Resonance and buyer demand remain untested."
  }
}
