{
  "title": "From a sale label to a studio decision",
  "research_date": "2026-11-22",
  "scope": "Traceable desk investigation of sale labels, token identity, source freshness, research methods and creative implications. Not a completed wallet-funding or beneficial-ownership audit.",
  "sample_rule": "First ten sale-labelled entries visible in the retrieved Botto profile snapshot, cross-checked against individual artwork-page recommendation blocks and linked token pages. Live bids, asks and unlabeled entries excluded. Not randomized or representative.",
  "contract": "0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D",
  "sample": [
    {
      "token_id": 44,
      "title": "Slow Crossing Iridescent Void",
      "displayed_eth": 0.49,
      "displayed_owner_label": "its0xalik",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/44",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 43,
      "title": "Leaf Dreams Larger Than Itself",
      "displayed_eth": 0.485,
      "displayed_owner_label": "encryptus",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/43",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 42,
      "title": "Rain Rewrites Everything",
      "displayed_eth": 0.464,
      "displayed_owner_label": "gpebbles",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/42",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 41,
      "title": "Striped Dissolution",
      "displayed_eth": 0.56,
      "displayed_owner_label": "0xd...969",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/41",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 40,
      "title": "Armchair Waits Under Sconce",
      "displayed_eth": 0.44,
      "displayed_owner_label": "ralgo",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/40",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 38,
      "title": "Ember Seam",
      "displayed_eth": 0.55,
      "displayed_owner_label": "thomahawk69",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/38",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 37,
      "title": "Black Basin Reads the Sky",
      "displayed_eth": 0.47,
      "displayed_owner_label": "hudsonsims",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/37",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 36,
      "title": "Plastic Devotion",
      "displayed_eth": 0.52,
      "displayed_owner_label": "ralgo",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/36",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 35,
      "title": "Palm Speaks What Mouth Cannot",
      "displayed_eth": 1,
      "displayed_owner_label": "sheer",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/35",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    },
    {
      "token_id": 34,
      "title": "Lichen Crowns Sleeping Patriarch",
      "displayed_eth": 0.62,
      "displayed_owner_label": "seethroughstudio",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/34",
      "evidence_class": "marketplace-labelled sale",
      "exact_settlement_price_verified": false,
      "transaction_hash": null,
      "settlement_date_verified": false,
      "buyer_independence_verified": false
    }
  ],
  "calculations": {
    "n": 10,
    "total_displayed_eth": 5.599,
    "median_displayed_eth": 0.505,
    "mean_displayed_eth": 0.5599,
    "min_displayed_eth": 0.44,
    "max_displayed_eth": 1,
    "distinct_displayed_owner_labels": 9,
    "top_displayed_owner_label_share": 0.2,
    "interpretation": "Labels only. No confidence interval for market prices; no inference of resale returns, trend or organic demand."
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "marketplace-sample",
      "title": "SuperRare: individual Botto 2026 artwork pages",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/artwork/eth/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D/44",
      "finding": "Ten visible sale-labelled comparison entries with linked token pages were recorded. Direct profile/collection reads sometimes returned loading or empty states while individual pages exposed recommendations.",
      "limit": "Convenience sample; ordering is not treated as a settlement chronology. Rounded ETH labels; dollar conversions excluded. Current owner labels do not identify original buyers or independent people."
    },
    {
      "id": "collection-census",
      "title": "SuperRare: Botto - 2026",
      "url": "https://superrare.com/collection/1-0x3cb787d48c34cca29653f54efc9112b4134b879d",
      "finding": "The accessible collection header displayed 45 minted works and 31 owners.",
      "limit": "An owner count is not a unique buyer count. A missing sale label is not evidence that a work failed to sell."
    },
    {
      "id": "cross-index",
      "title": "Verse: token 43",
      "url": "https://verse.works/items/ethereum/0x3cb787d48c34cca29653f54efc9112b4134b879d/43",
      "finding": "Search-indexed activity displayed 0.485 ETH. Direct artwork details confirmed contract/token identity and a November 4, 2026 mint timestamp, but the opened activity table exposed no rows.",
      "limit": "Cross-index corroboration only. Mint time is not sale time. Relative times from cached snippets are not converted into absolute settlement dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "auction-design",
      "title": "Botto auction documentation",
      "url": "https://docs.botto.com/overview/auction",
      "finding": "The documented process selects one work from 350 fragments through community voting, with a recurring auction schedule.",
      "limit": "A mature project with community incentives and an existing audience. Its results cannot be isolated to visual subject matter or transferred to a new studio."
    },
    {
      "id": "historical-category",
      "title": "DappRadar: State of the Dapp Industry Q3 2025",
      "url": "https://dappradar.com/blog/state-of-the-dapp-industry-q3-2025",
      "finding": "Provider reports $1.58 billion in NFT volume and 18.1 million sales for Q3 2025. The article carries an April 8, 2026 update label.",
      "limit": "The measurement period remains Q3 2025. The rounded arithmetic mean is about $87.29 per reported sale, across mixed categories. It is not a 2026 art price benchmark or a median."
    },
    {
      "id": "self-relevance",
      "title": "Vessel et al., Self-Relevance Predicts Aesthetic Appeal (2023)",
      "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09567976231188107",
      "finding": "Studies of 33 adults, a 208-person replication and a 45-person experiment link personal relevance with aesthetic appeal.",
      "limit": "Aesthetic ratings, not purchase behavior. Participant-tailored stimuli do not establish a universally appealing subject. Small experimental samples and no NFT conversion measure."
    },
    {
      "id": "self-relevance-correction",
      "title": "Erratum to Vessel et al. (2023)",
      "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09567976231201034",
      "finding": "The production correction restores an omitted open-practices statement. The studies were not preregistered; deidentified data and code are public.",
      "limit": "The correction does not supply NFT sales evidence or turn the findings into a forecasting rule."
    },
    {
      "id": "memory-emotion",
      "title": "Salgues et al., Self-reference and emotional reaction (2024)",
      "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-68331-9",
      "finding": "Two behavioral studies examine the relationship between self-reference, emotion, aesthetic judgments and memory.",
      "limit": "Some relationships differed between studies. Retrospective emotion ratings do not establish causation. This is not evidence of collector willingness to pay."
    },
    {
      "id": "emotional-range",
      "title": "Stamkou et al., Emotional palette (2024)",
      "url": "https://pure.uva.nl/ws/files/196072812/s41598-024-69686-9.pdf",
      "finding": "1,173 participants rated a set of 1,457 artworks; analysis identified 25 dimensions of aesthetic experience, with blends and gradients between categories.",
      "limit": "U.S.-registered participant sample; ratings of artworks, not NFT demand. A broad historical stimulus set does not guarantee equal cultural representation."
    },
    {
      "id": "sharing",
      "title": "Berger and Milkman, What Makes Online Content Viral? (2012)",
      "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1509/jmr.10.0353",
      "finding": "Study of New York Times sharing and experiments links sharing to activation and emotion, including awe, with roles for surprise and usefulness.",
      "limit": "News sharing in an earlier media setting. A share, a moving image and a purchase are different outcomes. No guaranteed viral creative formula follows."
    },
    {
      "id": "wash-method",
      "title": "Tosic et al., Beyond the surface (2025)",
      "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s40854-025-00766-z",
      "finding": "Method combines NFT ownership traces and historical ETH interactions to investigate linked trading. The authors discuss search-depth sensitivity and possible false positives.",
      "limit": "Heuristic suspicion is not proof of common beneficial ownership. Reported rates from seven collections cannot be assigned to the whole NFT market or to this comparison sample."
    }
  ],
  "access_log": [
    {
      "url": "https://etherscan.io/address/0x3cb787D48C34CcA29653F54EFc9112b4134b879D",
      "result": "403 Forbidden",
      "consequence": "No explorer transaction, funding-path, settlement-log or beneficial-ownership verification completed."
    },
    {
      "url": "https://superrare.com/botto",
      "result": "Search snapshot exposed sales; direct page exposed a loading/empty state.",
      "consequence": "Do not infer zero creations or unsold inventory from loading states."
    },
    {
      "url": "https://dappradar.com/reports",
      "result": "Retrieved index exposed 2025 reports; no suitable 2026 Q3 report verified.",
      "consequence": "Retain historical period labels; do not redate figures from page update/crawl timestamps."
    }
  ],
  "studio_inference": {
    "chapter": "After the Storm",
    "themes": [
      "care received",
      "visible repair",
      "refuge",
      "generosity",
      "renewal",
      "quiet contact"
    ],
    "hypothesis": "Specific relationships and ordinary consequential gestures may offer more points of personal connection than another polished object portrait.",
    "status": "Editorial hypothesis, not a measured audience result",
    "evidence_does_not_establish": [
      "that these themes command a price premium",
      "that high-arousal imagery converts to NFT purchases",
      "that more catalogue works increases sales",
      "that an AI agent independently bought a comparison work"
    ]
  },
  "next_validation": {
    "method": "Small opt-in qualitative review of a fixed six-work set; use the same display order rules and ask for reasons before revealing studio notes.",
    "questions": [
      "Which work stays with you after a short break?",
      "What detail or experience makes it matter to you?",
      "Which image would you send to someone, and why?",
      "Which original would you consider collecting under explicit terms?"
    ],
    "separate_outcomes": [
      "Recall",
      "Reason for attachment",
      "Willingness to share",
      "Qualified collecting enquiry",
      "Verified paid settlement"
    ],
    "status": "Prepared only. No participants recruited, messages sent, results invented or tracking installed."
  }
}
