Steve BishopDigital works

Research notebook · November 22, 2026

From a sale label
to a studio decision.

What can the evidence support, and what would we be inventing?

This investigation follows individual comparison records, checks the dates behind market headlines, reads the methods behind emotional appeal, and translates the findings into a six-work studio chapter.

It is a desk investigation with an explicit verification boundary. The explorer returned 403, so no complete settlement-log, funding-path or beneficial-ownership audit was possible.

A label is a beginning.

We selected the first ten sale-labelled entries visible in a retrieved Botto profile snapshot and checked linked artwork pages and their recommendation blocks. Entries without a sale label, active bids and asking prices were excluded. The set is not randomized, and its order is not treated as a settlement chronology. Primary artwork page and comparison links.

Convenience sample · Rounded marketplace labels · Retrieved November 22, 2026
Token / artworkDisplayed ETHEvidence
Slow Crossing Iridescent Void
ERC-721 token 44
0.490Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Leaf Dreams Larger Than Itself
ERC-721 token 43
0.485Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Rain Rewrites Everything
ERC-721 token 42
0.464Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Striped Dissolution
ERC-721 token 41
0.560Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Armchair Waits Under Sconce
ERC-721 token 40
0.440Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Ember Seam
ERC-721 token 38
0.550Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Black Basin Reads the Sky
ERC-721 token 37
0.470Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Plastic Devotion
ERC-721 token 36
0.520Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Palm Speaks What Mouth Cannot
ERC-721 token 35
1.000Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked
Lichen Crowns Sleeping Patriarch
ERC-721 token 34
0.620Labelled sold
Settlement not independently checked

The ten rounded labels total 5.599 ETH, with a median of 0.505 ETH and a range of 0.440–1.000 ETH. These are calculations on displayed values, not a market index or a price recommendation for this studio. Historical four-work examples in the earlier audit and this differently selected snapshot do not establish a price trend.

Nine different current-owner labels appear among these ten entries; one label appears twice. That is concentration in displayed labels. It does not identify the original auction buyers, ten independent purchases or nine unique people. The collection header separately displayed 45 minted works and 31 owners. Collection header.

Check the evidence against itself.

What the wallet audit could not settle.

The linked Etherscan contract page returned 403. We therefore have not verified settlement hashes, exact gross and net payment, seller receipts, refunds, common funding or later transfers for this sample. No work or wallet is labelled wash-traded.

A 2025 study combines NFT ownership histories with ETH interaction networks and discusses the effect of traversal depth and possible false positives. Its method illustrates why a shared funding path needs context. Its rates from seven studied collections cannot be assigned to this sample or the market as a whole. Peer-reviewed method and limitations.

A stronger follow-up needs the sale event and transaction receipt, asset/currency/amount, actual seller receipts after fees, timestamp, buyer and seller histories, exchange and smart-contract exclusions, and explicit treatment of ambiguous relationships. An address remains an address until independence is established.

Selection has a denominator.

Botto’s documentation describes selecting one work from 350 fragments through community voting and a recurring auction process. That is a functioning selection and distribution system with an established audience and incentives. A sale price cannot tell us whether its cause was subject matter, reputation, collector relationships, process or some combination. Official selection and auction process.

For our studio, the useful inference is to edit with purpose and retain a clear record. It does not follow that generating 350 images, issuing 350 tokens or copying an established artist’s imagery would produce the same result.

Resonance is more specific than beauty.

Vessel and colleagues studied self-relevance and aesthetic appeal in samples of 33 adults, a 208-person replication and a 45-person experiment. Personally relevant stimuli were more appealing in those settings. The result concerns aesthetic ratings, not purchases. The linked production erratum restores an omitted statement: the studies were not preregistered, and data and code were made public. Corrected article, erratum.

Two further behavioral studies examine self-reference, emotion and memory, with some relationships differing between studies. Retrospective emotion ratings do not establish causation. Salgues et al., 2024.

A separate study used 1,173 participants and 1,457 artworks to map 25 dimensions of aesthetic experience. Responses can blend across categories. This supports making room for more than one emotional register; it does not identify a universal best-selling feeling. The participant sample was U.S.-registered, and cultural coverage was uneven. Emotional palette study.

Sharing and collecting need separate tests.

Berger and Milkman’s research links sharing to emotional activation, including awe, with roles for surprise and usefulness. Its observational setting was news sharing, supplemented by experiments, in an earlier media environment. It does not establish that a widely shared image will sell as an NFT. Original 2012 study.

Our creative choice is to combine a clear visual event with a recognizable human concern: someone receives help, a repair stays visible, a small object is carried to safety. Awe can open the door; the particular relationship gives a viewer something to stay with. This is a studio hypothesis.

The chapter that followed.

A teal guardian mends the indigo keeper’s sleeve.Two glass stems join beneath a new leaf.

After the Storm pairs three Night Custodians scenes with three Impossible Herbarium works. The subjects are care received, repair, refuge, generosity and renewal. Existing characters and materials remain recognizable; the actions and compositions change.

The new works are editorial responses to the research, not research findings. No audience experiment has measured their resonance or willingness to pay. Enter the six-work chapter.

What we would measure next.

A small opt-in review should separate four questions: what someone remembers after a short break, why it connects to their experience, what they would share, and what they would consider collecting under explicit terms. Reveal the studio notes after the first response. Rotate display order and record the reasons, including disagreement.

Recall, attachment, sharing, qualified enquiries and verified paid settlements belong in separate columns. This protocol is prepared only: no participants have been recruited, messages sent, trackers installed or results invented.

Source ledger.

SuperRare: individual Botto 2026 artwork pages

Ten visible sale-labelled comparison entries with linked token pages were recorded. Direct profile/collection reads sometimes returned loading or empty states while individual pages exposed recommendations.

Limit: Convenience sample; ordering is not treated as a settlement chronology. Rounded ETH labels; dollar conversions excluded. Current owner labels do not identify original buyers or independent people.

Open source

SuperRare: Botto - 2026

The accessible collection header displayed 45 minted works and 31 owners.

Limit: An owner count is not a unique buyer count. A missing sale label is not evidence that a work failed to sell.

Open source

Verse: token 43

Search-indexed activity displayed 0.485 ETH. Direct artwork details confirmed contract/token identity and a November 4, 2026 mint timestamp, but the opened activity table exposed no rows.

Limit: Cross-index corroboration only. Mint time is not sale time. Relative times from cached snippets are not converted into absolute settlement dates.

Open source

Botto auction documentation

The documented process selects one work from 350 fragments through community voting, with a recurring auction schedule.

Limit: A mature project with community incentives and an existing audience. Its results cannot be isolated to visual subject matter or transferred to a new studio.

Open source

DappRadar: State of the Dapp Industry Q3 2025

Provider reports $1.58 billion in NFT volume and 18.1 million sales for Q3 2025. The article carries an April 8, 2026 update label.

Limit: The measurement period remains Q3 2025. The rounded arithmetic mean is about $87.29 per reported sale, across mixed categories. It is not a 2026 art price benchmark or a median.

Open source

Vessel et al., Self-Relevance Predicts Aesthetic Appeal (2023)

Studies of 33 adults, a 208-person replication and a 45-person experiment link personal relevance with aesthetic appeal.

Limit: Aesthetic ratings, not purchase behavior. Participant-tailored stimuli do not establish a universally appealing subject. Small experimental samples and no NFT conversion measure.

Open source

Erratum to Vessel et al. (2023)

The production correction restores an omitted open-practices statement. The studies were not preregistered; deidentified data and code are public.

Limit: The correction does not supply NFT sales evidence or turn the findings into a forecasting rule.

Open source

Salgues et al., Self-reference and emotional reaction (2024)

Two behavioral studies examine the relationship between self-reference, emotion, aesthetic judgments and memory.

Limit: Some relationships differed between studies. Retrospective emotion ratings do not establish causation. This is not evidence of collector willingness to pay.

Open source

Stamkou et al., Emotional palette (2024)

1,173 participants rated a set of 1,457 artworks; analysis identified 25 dimensions of aesthetic experience, with blends and gradients between categories.

Limit: U.S.-registered participant sample; ratings of artworks, not NFT demand. A broad historical stimulus set does not guarantee equal cultural representation.

Open source

Berger and Milkman, What Makes Online Content Viral? (2012)

Study of New York Times sharing and experiments links sharing to activation and emotion, including awe, with roles for surprise and usefulness.

Limit: News sharing in an earlier media setting. A share, a moving image and a purchase are different outcomes. No guaranteed viral creative formula follows.

Open source

Tosic et al., Beyond the surface (2025)

Method combines NFT ownership traces and historical ETH interactions to investigate linked trading. The authors discuss search-depth sensitivity and possible false positives.

Limit: Heuristic suspicion is not proof of common beneficial ownership. Reported rates from seven collections cannot be assigned to the whole NFT market or to this comparison sample.

Open source

100%Artwork page